Syed Huzaifah Ali Nadwi
Cambridge, UK

You open your phone and come across a short clip of a scholar answering a controversial question. The title promises a decisive response, the comments are full of arguments, and thousands of people have already shared it. You watch, perhaps agree with what is said, and forward it to a friend. A few moments later, another clip appears, this time of a different scholar challenging the same opinion. Before long, you have spent half an hour following a disagreement, formed a fairly strong view on the matter, and perhaps even joined the discussion yourself. Yet you may never have studied the subject in any meaningful sense.

I suspect many of us will recognise something of ourselves in this. We have become accustomed to following religious discussions almost as we follow the news. A new controversy appears, somebody responds, another scholar is drawn into the exchange, and the clips begin circulating. Within a few days, everyone seems to have an opinion. Then the discussion disappears, only to be replaced by another.

I have often wondered what we actually take away from all this. Are we learning more about our religion, or have we simply found another form of entertainment?

There is, of course, much to welcome in the accessibility of Islamic learning today. A student in Britain can attend lessons delivered in Cairo or Madinah without leaving home. Books that were once difficult to obtain can be consulted within minutes. Many people have developed a genuine interest in Islamic learning through a lecture or short reminder they happened to encounter on their phones. These are blessings for which we ought to be grateful.

But there is something troubling about the way religious disagreements have become a source of public excitement. A scholar expresses an opinion, another challenges it, and suddenly the discussion is no longer about the question itself. People are interested in who has responded, who has been silenced, and whose argument has prevailed. The comments beneath such videos can be particularly revealing. One finds confident judgements about matters of jurisprudence and theology from people who may never have studied even the introductory works of these disciplines.

Of course, one need not be a scholar to recognise a sound argument or question a weak one. But there is a difference between listening to an explanation and possessing the knowledge needed to evaluate it. A legal disagreement that has occupied generations of jurists cannot always be settled by a three-minute recording, however convincing the speaker may sound.

The Qur’an offers a rather different picture of what it means to seek knowledge. In Sūrat al-Kahf, when Mūsā (ʿalayhi al-salām) encounters the servant of Allah whom the exegetical tradition identifies as al-Khiḍr, he asks:

قَالَ لَهُ مُوسَىٰ هَلْ أَتَّبِعُكَ عَلَىٰ أَن تُعَلِّمَنِ مِمَّا عُلِّمْتَ رُشْدًا

Mūsā said to him, “May I follow you so that you may teach me some of the right guidance you have been taught?” (Qur’an 18:66)

There is much to consider in this brief exchange. Mūsā, himself a prophet, seeks to learn something that Allah has taught another of His servants. He asks permission to accompany him. The account that follows also concerns the difficulty of exercising patience when the reasons behind particular actions are not yet understood.

The circumstances of this Qur’anic account are quite different from ordinary religious study. Nevertheless, it reminds us of something easily forgotten: recognising that another person possesses knowledge we lack is itself part of learning. We do not always have the background needed to understand a matter immediately.

Our habits today often encourage the opposite. We encounter the disagreement before studying the subject. We hear the criticism before reading the opinion being criticised. We become familiar with the names of scholars through their controversies, sometimes without having read a single page of their writings.

There is also a danger in the confidence that comes from this kind of exposure. A person may listen to hundreds of lectures and become familiar with numerous religious questions, yet remain unable to explain the principles upon which those discussions depend. He may know which scholar holds which opinion, but not why the disagreement arose in the first place.

I am reminded here of the well-known ḥadīth narrated by ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAmr ibn al-ʿĀṣ (raḍiya Allāhu ʿanhumā), in which the Prophet ﷺ said:

إِنَّ اللَّهَ لَا يَقْبِضُ الْعِلْمَ انْتِزَاعًا يَنْتَزِعُهُ مِنَ الْعِبَادِ، وَلَكِنْ يَقْبِضُ الْعِلْمَ بِقَبْضِ الْعُلَمَاءِ، حَتَّى إِذَا لَمْ يُبْقِ عَالِمًا اتَّخَذَ النَّاسُ رُءُوسًا جُهَّالًا، فَسُئِلُوا فَأَفْتَوْا بِغَيْرِ عِلْمٍ، فَضَلُّوا وَأَضَلُّوا

“Allah does not take away knowledge by snatching it away from His servants. Rather, He takes away knowledge by taking away the scholars, until, when no scholar remains, people take ignorant individuals as their leaders. They are asked questions and issue religious judgements without knowledge, thereby going astray and leading others astray.”

(Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, no. 100; see also Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, no. 2673)

The ḥadīth is concerned with the disappearance of qualified scholars and the consequences of ignorance. It would be wrong to treat it as a direct description of our present circumstances. But its warning is worth considering at a time when religious opinions can circulate so widely, often without any indication of the learning or qualifications of the person offering them.

And what of the scholars themselves? There is a responsibility upon those who teach to resist the temptation to turn every disagreement into a public contest. Social media has made religious teaching more accessible, but it has also created an expectation that scholars should respond immediately to whatever happens to be attracting attention. A cautious answer, or an admission that a question requires further study, rarely generates the excitement of a forceful response.

Yet caution is often precisely what scholarship demands. The ability to speak confidently before a camera is no guarantee of sound judgement, and the number of followers a person attracts tells us very little about the depth of his learning. Some of the most accomplished scholars may have little public presence at all.

None of this is entirely new. Muslim scholars in earlier centuries also expressed concerns about popular preachers who sought the approval of their audiences through dramatic stories and impressive speech. Public preaching has always had the capacity to move people, and there is nothing objectionable about a lecture being engaging. The difficulty begins when the desire to hold an audience’s attention starts to determine what is taught and how it is presented.

We should also be careful not to place all the blame upon speakers. As listeners, we have our own habits to examine. How often do we return to a lecture to understand something we missed? How often do we consult the books being discussed? When we encounter a disagreement, are we genuinely interested in understanding both positions, or are we simply pleased to hear someone defend the opinion we already hold?

I do not think the answer is to abandon social media or expect everyone to undertake years of formal religious study. Many people have work and family commitments, and the opportunities available to them will differ. But if we already have an interest in these discussions, surely we can find ways of making that interest more beneficial.

A few changes might be a reasonable place to begin:

  1. Go beyond the short clip. If a discussion interests you, find the complete lecture or conversation. Listen to the original question and the explanation that follows. You may discover that the speaker’s position was more carefully qualified than the short recording suggested.
  2. Spend time with longer, serious discussions. A thoughtful podcast, a connected series of lessons or a detailed conversation with a qualified scholar can help us understand a subject more fully. Length alone is no guarantee of quality, but following an argument patiently is a habit worth developing.
  3. Find opportunities to ask questions. Attend a regular mosque lesson, join an organised online class or participate in a study circle. Look for settings where you can ask questions, hear different views explained and return to matters you have not understood. A discussion with a knowledgeable teacher will often be more useful than an argument in a comment section.
  4. Make something of what you learn. Take a few notes, return to a reference or try explaining a point in your own words. You do not need an elaborate system. Even a small amount of regular study can help you remember what you have heard and recognise where your understanding remains incomplete.

These are modest suggestions, and perhaps that is where we should begin. Most of us are not going to become specialists in Islamic law or theology, nor is that necessarily our aim. But we can become more careful about the material we consume, the opinions we repeat and the people from whom we take our religious knowledge.

There is considerable good in the lectures, reminders and discussions available to us today. I would be the last person to suggest that we should stop benefiting from them. My concern is simply that we should not allow the excitement of following religious discussions to replace the quieter, more demanding work of understanding our religion.

We have perhaps never had so much religious knowledge within our reach. The opportunity is there. What remains is for us to make better use of it.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top